Why is R indexing a vector with 0?

In R, you might be surprised to find that indexing a vector with 0 doesn't return the first element, nor does it cause an error. Instead, it returns an empty vector. This behavior is intentional and stems from R's design philosophy, which differs from many other programming languages that use zero-based indexing.

Here's a breakdown of why R behaves this way:

1. One-Based Indexing: R uses one-based indexing, meaning the first element of a vector is accessed using the index 1, the second with 2, and so on. This is a convention that aligns more closely with how humans typically count and is often considered more intuitive for statistical and mathematical operations.

2. Zero as a Special Case: When you use 0 as an index, R interprets it as a request to return "no elements." It's not an attempt to access a non-existent "zeroth" element. Instead, it's a way to create an empty vector of the same type as the original vector.

3. Practical Use Cases: This behavior is useful in several scenarios:

- Initializing Empty Vectors: You can use `vector[0]` to create an empty vector of the same type as `vector`. This is handy when you need to start with an empty container and add elements later.

- Conditional Subsetting: In some cases, you might have a condition that results in no elements being selected. Using 0 as an index ensures that you get an empty vector rather than an error, which can simplify your code.

4. Contrast with Zero-Based Indexing: Languages like C, C++, Java, and Python use zero-based indexing, where the first element is at index 0. This is a different convention, often rooted in how memory addresses are handled at a lower level. R's one-based indexing is more user-friendly for data analysis and statistical tasks.

5. Example:

# Example vector
my_vector <- c(10, 20, 30, 40, 50)

# Accessing the first element (one-based indexing)
first_element <- my_vector[1] # Returns 10

# Accessing with 0
empty_vector <- my_vector[0] # Returns an empty numeric vector: numeric(0)

# Checking the length of the empty vector
length(empty_vector) # Returns 0

In summary, R's behavior of returning an empty vector when indexing with 0 is a deliberate design choice that supports its one-based indexing system and provides a convenient way to handle empty selections and initialize empty vectors. It's a key aspect of R's unique approach to data manipulation and analysis.

Learn more about this