Why is the Java runtime not passing parameters with Hyphen to the script?

The reason why the Java runtime might not be passing parameters with hyphens correctly to a script typically stems from how the command-line arguments are parsed and handled by both Java and the operating system's command interpreter. Here's a breakdown of the common issues and solutions:

1. Command-line Argument Parsing:

- When you pass arguments to a Java application (or any executable), the operating system's shell (like bash, cmd, PowerShell) is the first to interpret the command line. It often uses whitespace to separate arguments. If your arguments contain special characters like hyphens, sometimes these might be misinterpreted or need special handling like being enclosed in quotes.

2. Java's `String[] args`:

- In Java, the arguments provided in the command line are made available to the `main` method as a `String` array named `args`. Java itself does not inherently modify the passed arguments, but it receives them after they've been processed by the shell.

3. Hyphens and Options/Flags:

- Often, command-line utilities and scripts use hyphens to denote options or flags. For example, `-v` might indicate "verbose output". If your script or the Java application expects specific arguments without treating them as options, this can lead to misinterpretation if you have hyphens in arguments.

4. Example Scenario:

- Let's say you intend to pass my-parameter as an argument to a Java application called MyClass. If you run it like this: java MyClass my-parameter, the Java program receives it as a regular argument and your script should receive it. But if you execute another command like: java MyClass -my-parameter , depending on how Java and the script you’re executing interpret parameters starting with a hyphen it could be interpreted as a flag and be handled incorrectly.

5. Solution - Quoting:

- The primary method to pass arguments with hyphens correctly is to enclose them in quotes, most of the time this means double quotes. This makes the shell treat the entire text inside the quotes as a single argument. For example: java MyClass "my-parameter-with-hyphen". This ensures that Java's `args` array receives `my-parameter-with-hyphen` as a single element, rather than trying to parse `my` `-parameter-with-hyphen` as separate parameters.

6. Solution - Script Handling:

- Another aspect of this is how your script handles arguments once it gets it. Make sure that the script you're passing the parameters to is ready to receive parameters that may contain hyphens.

7. Avoid Misinterpretations:

- If your intention is not to send parameters as options to your scripts, avoiding hyphens at the beginning of your arguments, can be a good solution.

In summary, the Java runtime itself doesn't alter the arguments passed to it. The issue mainly arises from the shell's interpretation of arguments and how you format the arguments that you’re passing. Quoting your parameters (especially those containing hyphens) is the recommended way to avoid these kinds of problems. If the script you are executing is interpreting parameters in a special way, you may need to review how it is handling those parameters.

Learn more about this