Why cannot Python import the name ModbusResponse in Modbus?

The reason you might be encountering issues importing `ModbusResponse` in Python when working with Modbus libraries is primarily due to how these libraries are structured and the specific classes they expose.

Here's a breakdown of common causes and how to address them:

1. Incorrect Import Path:

- The `ModbusResponse` class is not typically directly available at the top level of a Modbus library. Instead, it's often nested within a specific module or subpackage. For example, in `pymodbus`, response classes are usually found within the `pymodbus.pdu` module.

- Example (pymodbus): Instead of `from pymodbus import ModbusResponse`, you should use something like `from pymodbus.pdu import ModbusResponse` or a more specific response class like `ReadHoldingRegistersResponse`.

2. Library-Specific Implementation:

- Different Modbus libraries (e.g., `pymodbus`, `minimalmodbus`, `modbus_tk`) have their own internal structures and naming conventions. The class name `ModbusResponse` might not be used directly, or it might be an abstract base class not intended for direct import.

- Solution: Consult the documentation of the specific Modbus library you are using to find the correct import paths for response classes. Look for sections on PDU (Protocol Data Unit) or response handling.

3. Abstract Base Class:

- In some cases, `ModbusResponse` might be an abstract base class that defines the interface for all Modbus responses. You wouldn't import this directly; instead, you would work with concrete response classes like `ReadHoldingRegistersResponse`, `WriteSingleCoilResponse`, etc.

4. Incorrect Library Installation:

- Ensure that the Modbus library you intend to use is correctly installed. Use `pip install ` to install the library. If you're still having issues, try uninstalling and reinstalling the library.

5. Typo or Case Sensitivity:

- Double-check for typos in the class name and ensure that the case matches the library's definition. Python is case-sensitive, so `ModbusResponse` is different from `modbusresponse`.

Example using pymodbus:

from pymodbus.client import ModbusTcpClient
from pymodbus.pdu import ReadHoldingRegistersRequest, ReadHoldingRegistersResponse

client = ModbusTcpClient('127.0.0.1')
client.connect()

request = ReadHoldingRegistersRequest(address=0, count=10, unit=1)
response = client.execute(request)

if isinstance(response, ReadHoldingRegistersResponse):
  print("Successfully read registers:", response.registers)
else:
  print("Error reading registers")

client.close()

In summary, the key is to consult the documentation of your specific Modbus library and use the correct import paths for the response classes you need. Avoid directly importing a generic `ModbusResponse` unless the library's documentation explicitly instructs you to do so.

Learn more about this