What are the bits of `char s[0]`?

The question "What are the bits of `char s[0]`?" touches on the fundamentals of how characters are represented in computer memory, particularly in languages like C and C++. Let's break it down:

1. `char s[0]` - Array Declaration:

- The declaration `char s[0]` is a peculiar case. It declares an array named `s` of type `char` with a size of 0. In most contexts, this declaration is problematic and not practically useful because it doesn't allocate any memory for characters.

2. Accessing `s[0]` - Undefined Behavior:

- Attempting to access `s[0]` with a zero-sized array leads to undefined behavior. This means the compiler might not detect this as an error, and the program could potentially crash, exhibit unexpected behavior, or even seem to work fine under certain conditions, which makes debugging harder. Undefined behavior is dangerous because there is no guarantee what will happen.

3. Bits of a `char`:

- A `char` variable typically occupies 1 byte (8 bits) in memory. These 8 bits are used to encode the character based on a character set like ASCII or UTF-8. For example, the character 'A' is represented as 65 in decimal or 01000001 in binary (8 bits). But in the context of `char s[0]`, these bits are not applicable because no memory has been allocated for storing a character.

4. The Meaning of the Bits:

- If we were to imagine that `char s[0]` was valid (it is not!), then the bits would be related to the character it represents. Each bit of these 8 bits holds a 0 or 1 and, in combination, they form the numeric representation of the character, and could be interpeted as an integer value as well, if we consider `char` as a numeric type.

5. Why `char s[0]` is Problematic:

- The main problem is that by declaring `char s[0]`, there is no memory area allocated, and because of this, `s[0]` doesn't point to any valid memory address. If your code tries to access `s[0]`, you're potentially trying to read/write outside the bounds of what the program has allocated, resulting in the undefined behavior mentioned before.

6. Use Cases of Arrays of size 0

- There are cases where a 0 sized array could be used (mainly in C as an extension), but they are mostly used in structures as a trick for variable-length members. If you are not using a structure and trying to do that, it will result in an error. The code below shows how it is used:

struct my_struct {
int size;
char data[0];
};


This way you allocate the memory you need and read it as you need it, but even with that, this feature is not available in all compilers.

In conclusion, the "bits" of `char s[0]` are not meaningful because no memory is allocated for it. Accessing `s[0]` causes undefined behavior, and `char s[0]` should generally be avoided.

Learn more about this