Why does Map Key Override Equals not Work?

The behavior of Map keys overriding each other based on the equals() method depends on the specific programming language and the Map implementation being used. Here's a breakdown to help understand why it might not be working as expected:

1. Language-Specific Implementations:

- Java: In Java, HashMap and HashSet (which HashMap uses internally for keys) rely on both hashCode() and equals() methods of the key object. If you override equals() without also overriding hashCode(), you can violate the contract that equal objects must have equal hash codes. This will lead to incorrect behavior in maps, where equal keys might be stored in different buckets.

- JavaScript: JavaScript's Map object, introduced in ECMAScript 2015 (ES6), uses the SameValueZero algorithm for key equality. It generally checks for strict equality (===), not equals() methods. You will not have the same object considered as the same key if their values ​​are the same.

- Python: Python dictionaries use the hash of the object as the key. If two objects have the same hash value, then the last one added to the dictionary is the one that remains.

2. Importance of hashCode():

- For languages like Java, ensure that if a.equals(b) is true, then a.hashCode() == b.hashCode() must also be true. If not, HashMap will not behave correctly.

3. Example Scenario in Java:

- Suppose you have a class MyKey and you override the equals() method but forget to override hashCode(). The default hashCode() implementation in Java is based on object identity, so two distinct instances of MyKey, even if they are equal according to your equals() method, will likely have different hash codes. The map will treat them as different keys.

4. Incorrect Implementation of equals():

- Make sure your equals() method is correctly implemented according to the requirements of equivalence for your use case. A buggy equals() method can lead to unexpected behavior in maps.

5. Example Code (Java):

class MyKey {
  private int value;

  public MyKey(int value) {
    this.value = value;
  }

  @Override
  public boolean equals(Object obj) {
    if (this == obj) return true;
    if (obj == null || getClass() != obj.getClass()) return false;
    MyKey myKey = (MyKey) obj;
    return value == myKey.value;
  }

  @Override
  public int hashCode() {
    return Objects.hash(value); // Need to override hashCode!
  }
}


6. Testing Your Implementation:

- Always write unit tests to verify that your key object's equals() and hashCode() implementations work correctly with maps. This can help catch subtle bugs early.

In summary, ensure that you're using the correct key equality mechanism for your language, have correctly implemented the equals() method, and have paired it with a corresponding hashCode() method where required to ensure maps behave as expected.

Learn more about this